Follow
Share

I’ve been dealing with a challenging situation for the past year. My mother-in-law moved in with us under the impression that it would be temporary. Due to health reasons but has been healed for over 6 months. It was initially meant to be a short-term arrangement, but it has become long-term. Since her move, our family life has significantly changed. We used to be a close-knit family of three (my husband, our 9-year-old son, and me), but now our privacy is non-existent. My mother-in-law often yells at my son more than necessary and closely monitors everything we do, as her room is centrally located. She tells me how to parent an example would be; the other night my son was mad he had to get off his game so he was throwing a little fit. I went to go in his room and she yelled at me to stop and let him fuss. Her parenting was a joke from what her son has told me. I feel like I am shouldering all household responsibilities alone, which I never minded when it was just us 3, life was happy then. She has even started asking me to do things for my husband before he can even speak for himself, which makes me uncomfortable. Her presence has also led to tension between my husband and me. He spends more time at work and seems to be struggling with the situation too. I’m worried about the effect on our son, who seems to be more stressed and disconnected from his father. Additionally, my mother-in-law has her own house that she still pays for and her daughter and other grandchildren elsewhere, and I feel she’s becoming increasingly dependent on us. I’m concerned about my mental health and my son’s well-being. I don’t have a strong support network and am unsure how to address this with my husband, who can be difficult when discussing sensitive topics. I’m contemplating whether separation might be the only solution, but I’m unsure if that’s the best course of action. Has anyone experienced a similar situation? How did you handle it, and what strategies did you use to cope or resolve the issues? Any advice would be greatly appreciated.

Pack her bags and return her to her home.
If she will not go then consider moving YOURSELF into her home so she and your hubby can enjoy YOUR home.
If that doesn't work contact your preference of a divorce attorney or an eviction attorney.
Helpful Answer (22)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report
funkygrandma59 Aug 29, 2024
I LOVE your response Alva. What a great idea for the OP to move into her MIL's house if MIL won't move out.
I literally laughed out loud when I read what you wrote,
(12)
Report
See 4 more replies
There is one too many Queens in your Castle.

Unless you want to be enslaved & belittled, you must rise up, restore yourself as rightful Queen & banish the elder one.

I don't mean to trivialise or demonize. Mother's in law get enough bad rap.. But this situation pops up a LOT.
One Queen must rule.

This is accomplished by some hard chats. Be polite but FIRM.

Hard Chat #1. With Husband.
Time is up. Our GIFT of short-term accom for your Mother is now up.
Move her on. Back to her home or onto a sibling. But OUT.
Your Mom - your job. Start it.

Hard Chat #2. With MIL.
Sit down & present as a combined force. This is important. Some self-centered Mothers will attempt to stay #1 woman in their son's life Way Too Long. It needs to be crystal clear.. this is your marital home. MIL is a GUEST. Staying with your family was a GIFT. You came together when needed (that's what family is for) but now it is time to spread out again. That is healthy & respectful.

Plan your chats. Choose your style.

Pick a calm time to start as strong emotions can be unleashed. Be prepared for this to be process. (It would be amazing if one chat did it!)
Helpful Answer (22)
Reply to Beatty
Report
geostone Sep 6, 2024
Not that I disagree, but I think a lot depends on details we might not know regarding what the In-law agreed to. When I did it it might have been envisioned as short term, but I left it open I can complain now, but if I agreed to an open ended arrangement, it would feel weird to be so hardened.
(0)
Report
See 2 more replies
Hi Sadie, I lived your nightmare. We were a happy family of four my husband myself and our two daughters and then my MIL got here. My FIL passed away and she made everyone miserable because she was alone in her apartment. She cried all the time and always hinted about moving in with us and I never bit. Then she pulled the I can’t stay alone anymore I’m losing my mind. Well my husband’s brother and his wife were immediately on board to have her move in with them but that wasn’t good enough she wanted to share herself with everyone! So she got rid of her apartment and moved in with my BIL and SIL and kept trying for here. I protested and my husband and I fought constantly because I didn’t want her here. It was supposed to be a month here a month there and each month there was a two hour trip to go get her and a two hour trip to bring her back. The brothers met half way and she paid rent every month wherever she stayed. After holding her off for about 6 months she came here for her first month. If I can tell you it was a life changer and not in a good way. I used to be her favorite DIL we really got along well and she and I couldn’t stand my SIL but once she pulled this I put her on ignore all I could and whatever relationship we had was just gone because I felt so betrayed. So much so that instead of eating together I’d let them eat early and my daughters and I would eat later. She ruined our family life because my husband didn’t want to be the bad son when his brother and his brothers wife were all for it. They smelled money and figured it was best to keep her close by. So here a month there a month it was horrible! You’d just about start to feel like everything was normal and there she was walking back in the door again!
I should have mentioned that when my FIL a passed away she gave each of her sons $$$$. Then she split her bank accounts between her two sons. I told my BIL DO NOT spend that money it’s not yours and if she needs LTC Medicaid will come looking for that money. Well of course BIL didn’t listen spent all the money and MIL’s health started to decline. I dodged the bullet because I saw it coming and made up every excuse I could to stop her from coming here. I knew if she was here and she had a medical issue we’d be majorly screwed. So BIL and SIL got stuck dealing with everything because she was there when she fell in the bathroom and fractured both her knees after sliding in talcum powder they told her not to use! That was my worst fear that my daughters and I would end up being her caretaker because I knew my husband wouldn’t do a damn thing to help!
MIL passed away at 93 a year ago April but she really fractured our family and things are still not even close to being right. I have a lot of resentment towards my MIL and towards my husband because he didn’t honor his marriage vows and cleave to his wife! I get that he would have been fine with my mom being here BUT I would have taken care of her without a question and wouldn’t have shirked my duties like he would have. When you live with someone for decades you know them and you know their abilities to cope with caregiving. My husband would have run the other way instead of changing anyones diaper, or cleaning up vomit … My BIL on the other hand did that and more … any wonder why his wife was ok with it and I wasn’t?
So Sadie, my advice to you is get your MIL out before you really have a bigger problem than you do now. What happens if she gets sick? Are you ready to take on that role? Is your husband? Remember the longer she stays the more settled she’ll be and the harder it will be to show her the EXIT sign!
Helpful Answer (18)
Reply to Pegshere
Report

You need to have a serious conversation with your husband. It is not going to be easy because he is already trying to hide from the entire situation with work. Tell him you agreed to temporary and this is no longer temporary so what is the end date? Tell him either he needs to stand up and tell mom she needs to return home, or you will and you might not be nice about it. Give him a week to decide who delivers the news....you should do it together but we all know that probably won't happen. Own being the bad guy. This is for your son. Next time she oversteps a boundary or upsets your son, lay into her and lay into her hard. But be prepared that your husband may let you down and take mom's side. You will have to be prepared to walk away.
Helpful Answer (15)
Reply to lkdrymom
Report
Sadiesue23 Aug 29, 2024
Thank you so much for the advice. I've made myself sick today about it. I appreciate it more than you know.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
I remember when my moms mom moved in with us. I was about 12 and one day my grandma yelled at my dad. OOH my daddy just had enough. He said to her - this is my house you will not yell at me if you want to stay here. You can live here or get your own place but you will NOT yell at me in my house. That was the last time she yelled at him and she stayed. I don't know if my mama ever knew about daddy yelling at her mother but my parents were married until my mama's death.
So the point is... its your house and if you want peace and don't like what is going on you will need to take a stand. If MIL can take care of herself she will move if she doesn't like your conditions. Husband needs to wake up.
Helpful Answer (14)
Reply to Ohwow323
Report

PS if you want a softer approach..

A date night meal out with your husband would be a great starting point. Not even to chat about MIL but to reconnect. Plan a weekend away, take your son. To reconnect the 3 of you. Remind your Husband what familylife of 3 was like!

Then have a few date nights with your Husband. Start the chat about MIL. Make your plans together.
Helpful Answer (13)
Reply to Beatty
Report

Yeah, temporary move-ins are never temporary.
Helpful Answer (13)
Reply to olddude
Report
Belsnickles Sep 6, 2024
Yep. My mom was supposed to be here six months. We’re headed towards six YEARS.
(2)
Report
If this was temporary, she has heeled and she has a house to go to...time to go home. She is wearing out her welcome. Its time to tell her this arrangenent is no longer working, time to return to her own home. This is your home and MIL or not she does not tell you how to live in your home. She does not tell her how to raise your son. I doubt very much if she allowed her MIL to do it. Maybe your husband agrees with you but does not know how to approach her. Then you will need to be the bad guy and probably will suffer for it till her dying day. Again, just say not working mainly because she does not respect the standing you have in your own house. Its your house not hers. Your son, not hers. Time to go home.
Helpful Answer (13)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report
mgmbaker Sep 6, 2024
My husband and I both have mothers who require medical attention, and both are attention-seekers even aside from the medical issues. Both are now in care facilities (MIL is in AL, Mom is in MC). Both initially wanted to live with us. Thanks to this site and these people, we had the foresight to nip those ideas in the bud.

Until recent years, my MIL was a rock in my life and a mother figure because my own mother was such a bad mother (narcissist). I have loved MIL for nearly my whole life. She's changed since her husband died and has become a very difficulty person. For awhile, I was getting really frustrated and even angry at her because she was making my husband miserable by being childish and irrational. I finally realized I could turn my frustration into something constructive by taking on the bad guy role. Since then, I have found my frustration and anger have subsided and I am in a position to say the hard things to make things easier on Hubs, and on his brother and SIL.

We have learned the fine art of good guy/bad guy. Although I am the one to go face to face with my mother (or he with his), if I need to tell her something unpleasant, I strengthen my statements by saying "Hubs and I...". Her mind immediately makes him the bad guy because "surely her precious daughter wouldn't deny her own mother what she wants in her old age", but she's less likely to resist than if she thinks it's just me asking and she can manipulate me easier. We learned this as I was beginning to care for my mother, and it has carried over to care for my MIL. Where Hubs and his brother need to be able to keep lines of communication with their mom so they can steer her properly, I can be bluntly honest with her ("If you really love your sons, you'll take better care of yourself so they don't walk in and find you dead on the floor. Now let me give you your insulin"). She doesn't like it, and she doesn't like me very much (even though I know she loves me), but by somebody besides them speaking truth to her, they can negotiate with her better.

We recently went to a fashion show at MIL's AL, and after it was over, the families gathered with their dolled-up LO's for pictures. I was slow getting over there for my family and the director tried to get them to hold so I could jump in the picture. MIL said "She doesn't need to be in the picture". The director, a friend of mine, was standing near me and started to scold my MIL, but I stopped her and said quietly "It's okay. The good DIL is in the picture. I'm the evil DIL" and laughed. The other DIL took on a lot of MIL's daily care before she went to AL. My role has been to be the meanie and that means I don't make MIL happy a lot of times, but by being the bad guy, I give Hubs, BIL, and SIL an anchor to hold on to when they are trying to deal with MIL and she is giving them grief.

The key for us though, is communication between ourselves. I don't say or do unpleasant things with MIL if they aren't going to steer her to be more amenable to dealing with things I know Hubs and the others are trying to resolve. I also always make sure I am not speaking to her in anger because through it all, I do really love her and I don't want to hurt her unless it is for her own good.
(7)
Report
See 1 more reply
Tell your husband that this is not working out and that his mother has to leave . Her temporary stay is expired . She has taken over your home , marriage , family life . She either goes home or to assisted living .

Why is he afraid of her ? If he’s uncomfortable why hasn’t he told her to leave ? It was a temporary arrangement , so it should not be a shock that it’s time she goes . You and your child should be his priority . Go to marriage counseling . Your husband needs a reality check .
Also your MIL is in YOUR home . She does not dictate how things are done . Tell her that .
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to waytomisery
Report
MargaretMcKen Aug 29, 2024
I think action on MIL is easier on the marriage than expecting the leopard Husband to change his spots.
(0)
Report
See 2 more replies
I have lived through this. GET HER OUT. Your family stability and mental health is your priority. Assuming she can still live on her own, she needs to go home NOW.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to Srio2004
Report

See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter