I'm always curious about this. Not one person I know says they would be okay with one of their children having to help them with toileting, walking, etc. when they're older. I don't have kids so I don't know what the usual thinking is on this with parents.
Do any of you expect your kids to give you this level of care?
And "well they changed my diaper for me when I was a baby, I owe it to them" just kind of sounds like it's transactional care and guilt talking. But is that how people actually do feel about it?
Thanks for the insights, in advance :)
My in-laws (now just MIL) are successful narcissists that have no friends. My family has always been really their only "friends". They are not relational at all. So my MIL, in an independent living center, sits in her room and waits to come visit. She "doesn't like" any of the other 200 people there. She had one friend she dined with who is slipping into dementia.
My own parents flatly refused to move nearer to me or my brother, leaving the guilt of not being able to engage in care now because I am 11 hours away. Most all their friends moved away or are in care centers; my parents have just hunkered down and simmered in their anger about their situation.
One of my main hopes is that my husband and I can build a life going forward that is not DEPENDENT on our kids. Not physically, and not emotionally. I want us to have our own friends, our own activities, and our own support networks. I want to be somewhat near our kids so it is easier for them to lend support when we need it--but not too close. I hope for less than a two-hour drive from two of my kids so any necessary help can be shared, but I will used caregivers as much as I can.
My mother and my in-laws especially, are just too dependent emotionally on me and my family for their happiness. And the care and time I have given them has never, ever been enough.
I am not responsible for their happiness. I've spent a lot of time listening to clinical psychology teachings and realize that my family and my husband's family are both really broken. Specifically, they are both very immature (my dad was not, nor was his family). I have worked hard to understand this broken dynamic because I want it to be different for my kids.
The main thing I think I have learned in my years of this is it will be much easier on my kids later if my husband and I work actively to manage our own futures now. There is a different kind of resentment toward caregiving when the parents didn't at least try to take care of their own situations--like refusing for 30 years to tend to diet, to develop social groups, and to have their own lives. I can't tell you how resentful it makes me that my MIL is in a very nice independent living center, and refuses to engage in any social activities there.
I feel the less a parent expects from a child, the more that child is able to give willingly. I am already burned out from the parasitic nature of the family relationships over the last 40 years, and have NO positive emotions about taking care of either my mom or my MIL. I feel nothing but resentment.
I hope that, now that we have good forums and better care giving situations evolving, that my kids will have better direction about how to handle these many difficult elder care issues. I hope it will be different for them. The support and good information I have gotten from this forum has been more valuable than I can express.
I fell twice within one week. Last week, I went outside to take out the trash, missed a step and fell. Today, I went to change the clocks to normal time. I had been putting this off because I've been having some balance problems. I think the medications I'm taking is causing it. I need to check in with my doctor. I stood up in a chair, lost my balance, and knocked over a lamp. My cat ran. I'm sore, but not too bad yet. I can see why elders are afraid of showers and of falling.
Luckily for me I'm pretty strong willed and would probably risk more injury getting to the phone and calling 911.
In my case, there was no question....my poor father ended up in rehab after open heart surgery at 86. I was against the surgery, but one of the doctors told him that even if it was risky, that he would only be at risk by 15%...so, 85% he'd survive the procedure. This pleased my father and he happily agreed to have open heart surgery.
Well, he survived, but ended up in rehab because my mom couldn't care for him. She was blinded by macular degeneration. She'd lost her driving license years before, so she needed assistance as much as he did.
I had just moved out of state, and didn't realize the magnitude of what was happening.
I was close to both parents, and being that they were of the Greatest Generation, I trusted they'd be fine, because they'd always done well.
3 months after my father's procedure, he passed....a real shock for me, my mother, and sister...my sister lived nearby but was very busy with her life, plus, she's a business woman, not a caregiver! She told me this later.
Without any hesitation, I Began to drive back and forth to stay with my dear, sweet mom for 10-12 days, then drive home to see my hubs and care for the 16 cats we had...lots of work, ok.
My sister and I had Big Blowup...mainly because she didn't want to have Mother with her all the time....my sister lost her job and home, and had moved in with Mom....but she hated having to take Mom out with her. Meanwhile, I lost my home too! It was the housing collapse of 2012....finally, after our Blowup, I ordered my sister gone...and my mother and I filed a police report on my sister's abusive behavior....I'm skipping details, ok.
On January 4, 2014, my hubs and I moved Mother out with us, and gave her home to my sister.
Fair deal....and, from then on, I became my mom's full time caregiver until I lost her in 2018....I have Zero regrets....but, I do regret not acting fast enough to help my poor dad. He didn't last long in rehab....so, that was a tragedy.
I would do it all again in a heartbeat...my mom was my sweet angel, sent to me by God....and she's worth more to me than my life. So, now I'm still here, don't know why...but I guess the Lord has me here for a reason...I cling to God!! There's nothing else, no one else can make me smile like Christ!
And, yes, our parents, namely our mothers, did sacrifice all for us! The least I could do was take her in, give her the best I had to offer, and laugh with her, even tho watching her decline put me into a deep anticipatory grief...but, I'd do it all again, and with honor and gratitude to the Lord for letting me have her as long as He did. She passed just before turning 95.
I miss her terribly, and after nearly 4 years later, I cry, I write about her, and any dreams I have of her, I faithfully write down.
I was her seeing-eye daughter, and she was my everything!
Shalom! 💜🕊💜
As my mom had health issues, life-changing surgery and then later had progressively declining health my support level for her changed over the course of 11 years.
She was a baby boomer. I'm a younger Gen Xer.
We never talked about me "taking care of her." She always wanted to live on her own and do her own thing and I was happy to let her do so as we lovingly butt heads about what I should and shouldn't do with my life or in my home. :-)
She had a stroke shortly before I relocated to a new state. Although she recovered fairly well, she couldn't drive or take public transportation alone anymore.
She joined me in the new state and moved in with me and my two toddlers. At first she only "needed me" for rides to the store, to run errands that were too hard, pick up heavy stuff, that sort of thing. She was my afterschool care and babysitter and even cooked for us frequently.
The fact of the matter is, unexpected necessary surgery and the resulting issues put me unexpectedly in a caregiver role.
I just reacted from that point on until years later when I had the wherewithal, knowledge and burnout to realize I needed to do some things differently.
We were not economically well off, so paying for private help was not an option and she was on Medicare which did the major and basic things, but not ADLs.
I know she cared for her mother when she became ill and to some extent, yes, I think she expected me to do whatever was needed with no questions even though she also was frustrated and embarrassed by her need for the assistance.
That being said, what do I expect from my children?
I expect them to help me as much as I NEED them to, but I am working to make sure they know I want them to utilize whatever aides, therapists, etc. that are available and affordable using my insurance, personal funds, etc so they are not burdened.
I don't want them to have to help me with toileting or dressing wounds, etc. but they may need to do so at some point. We don't know what the future holds. For me the main things is I don't want to guilt them into not asking for or seeking paid help and I plan to be very agreeable to accepting help from my friends and/or their friends for things that are less personal so my kids aren't stretched thinly.
Personally it would have been easier to handle the gross/intimate things if I had someone else to take mom to appointments, to the store, etc. and if I could have gotten her out of the house for a few hours every week to have a mental break.
Her personality plus her unique health challenges combined with my embarrassment about a cluttered home and my reluctance to ask for help made that difficult, especially in those last few years.
I hope I haven't been rambling, but now that I've gone around the world, short answer below:
I expect my kids to show me respect and love out of their love for Christ and their love for me which I endeavored to nurture all their lives.
I expect my kids to help me make good decisions about my life and health as long as I'm mentally competent to make my own decisions. Should I lose that mental capacity, I expect them to act in my best interests as they would want someone to do for them.
I expect them to discern what tasks should and can be delegated and what tasks they need to do themselves. Factors include: professional/technical expertise required? Safety issue? Parent's comfort level w/ other people? Practicality/scheduling? Personal preference (of me as parent and them as the child).
Short term family helps people who are sick and recuperating all the time even with things like going to the bathroom. Long term it's healthy to get help if at all possible.
With all of this I’ve wondered who will take care of me since have no spouse or kids. I had originally designated another brother for account beneficiary, executor, etc. but he has been thoroughly disengaged with our brother and his care. My niece offered to take care of all this when I said I didn’t trust him. I was shocked! So I’m changing things in my will. I said that if it comes time that I need more care I’m willing to move closer to her (she’d love it if I moved there next week). I want her to research and find the best AL or NF for me. I’m also writing a letter to her that will include friends who will help her, as well my instructions to move me closer to care for me if I can’t take care of myself. I used to be a CNA so I get the care involved!
To be sure there are terrible NF out there but there are also excellent ones. But a lot of people generalize the horror stories and say they’ll never go there or put a parent there. By then the elderly parent has lived a full life. Why can’t their children do the same? People who choose to do caregiving have no idea what they’re in for.
I think that if twenty or thirty years ago you had asked our cared-for loved ones of now whether they expected their personal care needs to be supplied by their children you would probably have got "no!" across the board.
So. I think we'd better assume there's a radical change in perspective somewhere down the line, and it's probably not safe to say until we get there.
suddenly when one is vulnerable/helpless (older/frail), one might suddenly want help, although one previously strongly said one didn't.
however --
i have friends (elderly), who on purpose planned things very well, knowing exactly this might happen. they absolutely didn't want their children to be given all the stress/problems.
even when adult children aren't doing hands-on care, there can still be millions of problems/stress, as shown again and again by all of us on this website (whether you help hire in-home care; advocate for LO in a facility; whatever form the help takes, it can be A LOT of NON-STOP stress).
these friends i have, planned well in advance; talked well in advance with their children about their wishes.
when i say planned: i don't mean that one must plan to be in a facility.
planning can take on many forms.
yes of course, not everything can be planned/foreseen.
BUT to the best of one's ability, one CAN plan for old age.
old age has literally existed forever (what age is old age changed, but "old age" always existed).
one can always make excuses for various things.
the thing is, some people really (i feel) could have, should have, planned better, so as to avoid stealing their adult children's life (their good heart, kindness).
i'm not at all saying we shouldn't help our parents.
there are, however, so many examples, where the help needed is so extreme, and some things could indeed have been better planned, so as to avoid THAT MUCH stress on the adult children.
:)
I take much better care of myself than my mother did. I hope to be more independent than she was. If I need help I would hope to have it in my own environment. I also fear too much longevity especially if in a physically compromised state.
My husband and I have set up our financials so that there should be money if we need care especially if our house is sold. I would have no problem downsizing if need be.
I am 65 and do some form of exercise 6 days a week. I eat well and watch my weight. I seek medical attention when needed and stay on top of testing that is suggested as I age. I don't have any serious vices.
I realize all this may not be enough one day but I try as best I can to advocate for myself. We have wills and medical directives assigning POA's. Beyond all that I just hope I can age gracefully. I do not want my children to be burdened with my care. I only hope to stay connected with them and hopefully with my grandchildren who we have invested time with and formed positive relationships. I was very close to one grandmother who made it to 98. I always remembered my earlier years with her and she had profound influence on my life especially at times when my mother was not always emotionally present. Beyond all that I just look to God to help me through what my future may bring. I would like to emulate the queen of England without all the matching outfits and the large staff. I hope to remain proud of my children. I hope none of them find themselves divorced having had divorced parents yet I know there certainly are circumstances that may be for the best for some and if that is the case I hope their future unions bring them peace.
I hope my world is surrounded by positive influences and void of crime. I am basically a kind person and treat others with respect. I hope the same is shown to me.
Because my children have seen me care for their grandparents (my in-laws, both in their 90s), they have come to appreciate that it requires a self-sacrificing spirit to care for them full-time. Both require assistance with daily personal hygiene, walking, help with toileting, turning in bed, wound care, range of motion exercises, providing recreation, giving them individual emotional and spiritual support... In our home, our goal is to help them to thrive, not just merely survive. Occasionally, my children have traveled to come to visit and have assisted me in rendering care. My son has admitted, because I have a nursing background that he probably will not be able to do everything as well as I do, but has assured me that whatever he and his wife can do for me (when the time comes and I am elderly, disabled and in need of their assistance) they will do to the best of their ability.
I said, yes. That would be okay.
Our faith has taught us the value of talking about such matters and to explore prospective specific plans of action that each family member can do or is willing to consider realistically doing. We believe that discussing these things ahead of time, helps us to be prepared to meet challenges along the way. I have my wishes in writing in a living will and have given my family members copy.
My husband and I are working on having everything in place to where our son does not have to "guess" what our wishes are or feel like he has to perform any hands-on care. We do not expect that from him. Historically, both sides of our families (especially mine) have lived very independent and pretty healthy lives until one day they just pass on. We've had a few outliers over the years, with my mom being one. That's another story. You never know what is in store for your future, however, so it's best to have a plan.
Becoming parents was a choice that we gladly made and we don't expect nor want him to feel obligated to "repay" us further down the line.
I have discussed dementia and physical limitations with my kids and instructed them that they are not to give up their futures (they’re all still in school) - their careers, their children, their spouses and their lives, to care for me. Sure, I have a much different personality than my own mother. (it seemed like dementia poked holes in the few filters she ever had) My kids are certain I won’t morph into a Queen Bee, and, frankly, I’m hilarious - not the type to ooze negativity. But, one never knows. Let the pros help me with daily care so my relationship with my kids can continue without fear, guilt or resentment. My husband and I are very close with our kids (although they fight with each other) and our job, as we see it, is to set an example and prepare them for adulthood. We’re trying to simplify the upkeep of our home (my rustic dream home in the woods) but we recognize it will one day be too much. That is for us to resolve bit by bit, and not a burden to be dumped on our kids.
i see you are.
you've made me smile/laugh/learn, reading your various posts.
hugs!! :)
In Feb. 2019, my widowed father-in-law became very ill. My husband flew to his father's Texas home, everyone fully expecting him to be taking care of funeral arrangements. My FIL recovered, but the doctors said he could no longer live alone. I flew to join my husband in Texas to care for my FIL. We thought it would be 3-6 months, at most. Here we are, three years later, still here, living in the 2nd bedroom of FIL's 2 bedroom home. His doctor has told us that if we were not here and he'd tried to live at home, he probably would have died that first year we were here. He has been diagnosed with dementia and the onset of Alzheimer's, but he is not so far "gone" that he needs -- or will agree to -- going into a Memory Care facility. We made the choice to stay here and help him stay in his home as long as possible, because all research we've read indicates that staying at their home tends to extend the elderly person's life. We don't regret the decision, even though it has been very difficult, with his memory and cognitive problems causing some real issues. We know that it is likely that eventually his care will be more than we can handle (when he is unable to bathe/dress/feed himself), and it will be time for a facility.
I would prefer that neither of our sons have to go through this, and if they do not wish to, I will understand. But, having been the caregiver, if I ever DO need care and one of them says he wants me to live with him so he can oversee my care and my affairs, I would be touched...and my prayer would be to always appreciate his time and attention, and let him handle whatever he wants to handle. I hope that if/when the time comes, I will graciously accept that there are things I am no longer able to do, and accept help. I definitely do not expect either of my sons to ever take on bathing, dressing, or feeding me. IMO, that's when it's time for Assisted Living.